Lease Accounting Under ASC 842: Finance vs Operating, Worked in Full
Kyle Ashcraft, CPA · 2019 CPA Exam Scores · 95 FAR · 98 BEC · 91 REG · 90 AUD
Leases are among the most journal-entry-heavy topics on FAR, and most candidates study them the hardest possible way: memorizing each entry as a separate fact. There are a lot of entries and they look unrelated, so the memorizing never finishes.
They are not unrelated. The same three things happen every year of every lease, and once you can name those three things, the entries stop being facts to recall and become consequences you can derive. This article works one example twice, first as a finance lease and then as an operating lease, so you can see exactly where the two paths split and why.
In this article
Prefer the app? Watch the lease walkthrough on YouTube.
Practice the entries as you read
Work the entries yourself in the tool below, then come back to the walkthrough. Reading a completed journal entry and producing one from a fact pattern are different skills, and only the second one is tested.
Is it a finance lease or an operating lease?
Five criteria. Meeting any one of them makes it a finance lease. Meeting none makes it an operating lease.
| Criterion | Test |
|---|---|
| Transfer of ownership | Title passes to the lessee by the end of the lease term |
| Purchase option | The lease contains an option the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise |
| Lease term | The term is a major part of the asset's remaining economic life, commonly read as 75% or more |
| Present value | The present value of the lease payments plus any lessee-guaranteed residual value is substantially all of the fair value, commonly read as 90% or more |
| Specialized asset | The asset is so specialized it has no alternative use to the lessor at the end of the term |
The first two and the fifth are about ownership effectively passing. The middle two are arithmetic.
75% and 90% are guidelines, not bright lines. The standard describes "a major part" and "substantially all," and permits those percentages as reasonable readings. That is a deliberate change from the old rules-based approach, and it means an exam question sitting near the boundary will give you enough context to decide rather than expecting you to apply a hard cutoff.
One exception to the lease term test. It is not applied when the lease begins at or near the end of the asset's economic life, generally the final 25%. A two-year lease on a machine with two years left would otherwise be 100% of remaining life and would force finance treatment for no sensible reason.
Work the criteria in order and stop at the first one met. Candidates lose time here checking all five when the answer was settled at the first, and lose points by assuming several must be met when one is enough.
What is actually happening in every lease?
Three things, running in parallel, from commencement to the end. Every entry you will ever write on this topic is one of these three.
- The liability grows as the discount unwinds. You recorded the obligation at present value, which is less than the cash you will actually pay. That gap closes over time, and the closing is interest.
- The liability shrinks as you pay. Each payment reduces it. By the last payment it is zero.
- The right-of-use asset is written down to zero. For a finance lease that happens through amortization expense. For an operating lease it happens as a plug.
Both lease types do all three. The difference is only in how the third one is measured and how the result is presented on the income statement. That is the whole topic.
The example
One fact pattern, run twice.
| Commencement | December 31, Year 1 |
|---|---|
| Lease term | 3 years |
| Annual payment | $50,000, paid at the end of each year, so an ordinary annuity |
| Implicit rate | 10% |
| Annuity factor | 2.49 for three years at 10% |
| Present value | $50,000 × 2.49 = $124,500 |
For the finance lease version, the useful life is 4 years and title transfers to the lessee at the end of the lease. Criterion one is met.
For the operating lease version, the useful life is 6 years and the asset reverts to the lessor. The term test gives 3 of 6 years, or 50%, which is not a major part, and no other criterion is met.
The commencement entry is identical either way
Cr Lease Liability 124,500
Classification changes nothing on day one. Both types put the asset and the obligation on the balance sheet at present value, which was the central point of ASC 842: operating leases stopped being off balance sheet.
When the two figures differ. The right-of-use asset equals the liability only in a clean fact pattern. It is also increased by payments made at or before commencement and by initial direct costs, and decreased by lease incentives received. Exam questions that hand you a signing bonus or a broker fee are testing whether you adjust the asset and leave the liability alone.
The liability schedule, common to both
Interest accrues at 10% on the opening balance, the payment comes off, and the remainder carries forward.
| Year | Opening | Interest at 10% | Payment | Principal | Closing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 124,500 | 12,450 | 50,000 | 37,550 | 86,950 |
| 2 | 86,950 | 8,695 | 50,000 | 41,305 | 45,645 |
| 3 | 45,645 | 4,355 | 50,000 | 45,645 | 0 |
| Total | 25,500 | 150,000 | 124,500 |
Two checks worth doing on any schedule you build. Total interest of $25,500 is the difference between the $150,000 of cash paid and the $124,500 recorded, which is the discount unwinding exactly as it should. And total principal equals the opening liability.
Year 3 interest is a plug. Ten percent of $45,645 is $4,564.50, not $4,355. The gap exists because the 2.49 annuity factor is rounded from 2.486852. In the final year you force interest to whatever brings the liability to zero, which is standard practice and standard on the exam. If your last year does not close out cleanly, look for a rounded factor before you look for an error.
Finance lease entries
Two expenses, recorded separately: interest on the liability, and amortization of the asset.
The amortization period is the trap
The lease term is three years. The amortization period is four.
Where ownership transfers, or a purchase option is reasonably certain to be exercised, the right-of-use asset is amortized over the useful life of the underlying asset, because you are going to keep using it after the lease ends. In every other finance lease you use the shorter of the lease term or the useful life.
Year 1, ending December 31 Year 2
Dr Lease Liability 37,550
Cr Cash 50,000
Amortization Dr Amortization Expense 31,125
Cr Accumulated Amortization 31,125
Years 2 and 3
Same two entries, new interest figure from the schedule. Amortization never changes.
Dr Lease Liability 41,305
Cr Cash 50,000
Dr Amortization Expense 31,125
Cr Accumulated Amortization 31,125
Year 3 Dr Interest Expense 4,355
Dr Lease Liability 45,645
Cr Cash 50,000
Dr Amortization Expense 31,125
Cr Accumulated Amortization 31,125
The liability is now zero and the lease is over. But the asset has one year of amortization left, because you own it.
Cr Accumulated Amortization 31,125
The expense pattern
| Year | Interest | Amortization | Total expense |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 12,450 | 31,125 | 43,575 |
| 2 | 8,695 | 31,125 | 39,820 |
| 3 | 4,355 | 31,125 | 35,480 |
| 4 | 0 | 31,125 | 31,125 |
| Total | 25,500 | 124,500 | 150,000 |
Expense declines every year. Amortization is flat, so the entire slope comes from interest falling as the liability shrinks. That front-loading is the defining feature of a finance lease and the reason the classification matters to anyone reading the statements.
Operating lease entries
One expense line, the same amount every year.
Interest is still accruing internally on the liability, exactly as in the finance lease. It just never appears as its own line. Instead the reduction of the right-of-use asset absorbs whatever is left of the $50,000 after the interest portion, which is why it is called a plug.
Dr Lease Liability 37,550
Cr Cash 50,000
Cr Right-of-Use Asset 37,550
Year 2 Dr Lease Expense 50,000
Dr Lease Liability 41,305
Cr Cash 50,000
Cr Right-of-Use Asset 41,305
Year 3 Dr Lease Expense 50,000
Dr Lease Liability 45,645
Cr Cash 50,000
Cr Right-of-Use Asset 45,645
Where the plug comes from
| Year | Lease expense | Interest inside it | ROU reduction | ROU balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 50,000 | 12,450 | 37,550 | 86,950 |
| 2 | 50,000 | 8,695 | 41,305 | 45,645 |
| 3 | 50,000 | 4,355 | 45,645 | 0 |
| Total | 150,000 | 25,500 | 124,500 |
Look at the last two columns of both schedules. In an operating lease the right-of-use asset and the lease liability decline by identical amounts every year and reach zero together. That is a fast way to check your work, and it is not true of a finance lease, where the asset amortizes on its own schedule.
The 6-year useful life never gets used. It appears in the fact pattern only to fail the term test, since three years out of six is 50%. Once the lease is operating, expense is straight-lined over the lease term and the asset's life is irrelevant. Unused numbers in a lease question usually did their work at the classification stage.
Side by side
| Finance lease | Operating lease | |
|---|---|---|
| Commencement entry | Identical. ROU asset and lease liability at present value. | |
| Income statement | Two lines: interest expense and amortization expense | One line: lease expense |
| Expense pattern | Front-loaded and declining | Straight-line and level |
| ROU written down over | Useful life where ownership transfers, otherwise the shorter of term or useful life | The lease term, as a plug |
| Cash flow statement | Principal in financing, interest in operating | The whole payment in operating |
| Balance sheet | Both present a right-of-use asset and a lease liability | |
The same total, in a different shape
| Year | Finance | Operating | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 43,575 | 50,000 | (6,425) |
| 2 | 39,820 | 50,000 | (10,180) |
| 3 | 35,480 | 50,000 | (14,520) |
| 4 | 31,125 | 0 | 31,125 |
| Total | 150,000 | 150,000 | 0 |
Both recognize $150,000, which has to be true, because $150,000 is what leaves the bank. Classification does not change the total cost of anything. It changes when the cost lands and how many lines it occupies.
Note also that this particular finance lease runs a year longer than the lease itself. That is the title transfer at work, and it is why the year 4 column is not a rounding artifact.
Why the cash flow row matters. A finance lease moves most of the payment out of operating cash flow and into financing, which improves operating cash flow without changing a dollar of actual cash. If a question asks about the effect of classification on the statement of cash flows rather than on net income, that row is the answer.
The traps
| The trap | What is actually true |
|---|---|
| Thinking several criteria must be met | One is enough. Check them in order and stop at the first hit. |
| Amortizing a finance lease over the lease term by default | Where ownership transfers or a purchase option is reasonably certain, use the useful life. Otherwise the shorter of term or useful life. |
| Treating 75% and 90% as bright lines | They are guidelines for "major part" and "substantially all." |
| Assuming an operating lease has no interest | Interest accrues on the liability exactly as in a finance lease. It is simply folded into one expense line instead of shown separately. |
| Assuming the ROU asset always equals the liability | True in a clean fact pattern. Initial direct costs and prepayments raise the asset; incentives received lower it. |
| Panicking when the final year does not close to zero | Almost always a rounded annuity factor. Plug the final period's interest. |
| Forgetting the short-term exception | A lease of twelve months or less with no purchase option the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise can be elected off balance sheet, with expense recognized straight-line. |
Start free with CPA 101
Practice all 25 of the 2026 AICPA released MCQs, plus a free study outline. FAR, AUD and REG tracks available. No credit card required.
Where does Maxwell CPA Review fit?
Concessions first. If you want the largest question bank available, that goes to Gleim or UWorld. If your firm sponsors a course, it is usually Becker, and there is no reason to decline something already paid for. If you want adaptive software that scores your readiness, Surgent does that better than I do.
What Maxwell CPA Review does is different, and leases are the clearest example on the whole exam. Every other option in this category answers a shortage: more questions, longer explanations, more visuals. Maxwell answers a surplus. Leases are a high-yield topic, so we work the journal entries from commencement to the end of the lease life, once, properly. That is more useful than fifty lease questions attempted before the pattern is in place.
Here is what is in the FAR section:
| Video lessons | 7 hours |
|---|---|
| Practice MCQs | 800 |
| Task-based simulations | 36 |
| Textbook | 233 pages |
| Study outlines | 74 pages |
| Also included | Baseline assessment, final review, mock exam, 10 interactive apps |
Across the whole course: 50 hours of video content, 5,000 practice MCQs and 150 task-based simulations, covering all six sections, FAR, AUD, REG, BAR, ISC and TCP, with no discipline upcharge. Built to the current AICPA Blueprint, with every lecture, textbook and outline created by one CPA who scored a 95 on FAR.
Best for candidates who can follow a worked entry but cannot produce one: Maxwell CPA Review, with bite-sized lessons focused on the concepts that matter most, at $49 per month, billed monthly, cancel anytime.
Use it as your primary course. Use it to retake a section you failed. Use it alongside what you already bought.
Frequently asked questions
What are the five finance lease criteria?
Transfer of ownership, a purchase option reasonably certain to be exercised, a lease term covering a major part of the remaining economic life, a present value of payments amounting to substantially all of fair value, and an asset so specialized it has no alternative use to the lessor. Meeting any one makes it a finance lease.
Are 75% and 90% still bright lines?
No. The standard uses "a major part" and "substantially all," and permits those percentages as reasonable interpretations. Questions near the boundary give you enough context to decide rather than expecting a hard cutoff.
Over what period is a finance lease right-of-use asset amortized?
Over the useful life of the underlying asset where ownership transfers or a purchase option is reasonably certain to be exercised, because the lessee keeps using it after the lease ends. In all other finance leases, over the shorter of the lease term or the useful life.
Do operating leases go on the balance sheet?
Yes. Under ASC 842 both lease types recognize a right-of-use asset and a lease liability at present value. That was the main change from the previous standard, where operating leases stayed off balance sheet.
Is there interest in an operating lease?
Yes, the liability accretes at the discount rate exactly as in a finance lease. It is simply not presented separately. The single lease expense equals the interest plus a plug reduction of the right-of-use asset, so the asset and the liability decline by identical amounts and reach zero together.
How do the two lease types differ on the cash flow statement?
A finance lease splits the payment, with principal in financing activities and interest in operating. An operating lease reports the entire payment in operating activities.
What happens if the final year of the schedule does not reach zero?
It is almost always a rounded present value factor. Force the final period's interest to whatever amount brings the liability to zero. Total interest should then equal total payments less the amount originally recorded.
Is there an exception for short leases?
Yes. A lease of twelve months or less that contains no purchase option the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise can be elected out of recognition, with the payments expensed on a straight-line basis over the term.
Ready to work more than one lease?
Start with the 2026 AICPA released questions and the free study outline, and see whether the explanations work the way you need them to.
Kyle Ashcraft, CPA scored 90 or above on every section of the CPA exam in 2019, including a 95 on FAR. He is the founder and sole instructor of Maxwell CPA Review, where he creates every lecture, textbook and study outline himself.
Reach him at MaxwellCPAreview@gmail.com.
Explore More Comprehensive CPA Guides
Master operating and finance leases, journal entries, and amortization schedules.
The ultimate cheat sheet for turnover, liquidity, and profitability ratios.
Break down variance analysis, job costing, and activity-based costing (ABC).
Understand NPV, IRR, payback period calculations, and investment decisions.
Simplify macro and microeconomic concepts, supply, demand, and market structures.
Navigate relational databases, IT governance, segregation of duties, and cybersecurity.